
I promised Tansy I would blog this, so here goes. Don't expect quality, I'm watching the telly for a start.
I picked up China Mieville's
Un Lun Dun at the library, under the mistaken beliefs that
1) it was steampunk, and
2) China Mieville was a woman, coz I'd been feeling a bit gender-biased in my reading.
Instead, it turns out that there are blokes out there called China, and that Un Lun Dun was really more akin to a modern Alice in Wonderland urban fantasy kind of production.
I found it very slow to get into; this was partly because the main characters are called Zanna and Deeba, which I found irksome. Eventually, lured by a broken umbrella, they make their way to London's dark twin, the abcity UnLondon, where Zanna, the Shwazzy (
choisi - chosen one) is expected to save the unciviisation from unusually militant and personalised smog.
Once it hits UnLondon, the story really does get interesting.
At a superficial level, this is because Mieville piles bizarre character on bizarre character, and incident on incident, in such a throwaway manner that you feel he has crazy ideas to spare, and that another writer would have got a good ten books out of the material he is lobbing around so carelessly (and perhaps that his editor was overwhelmed by the volume - it is a damn long book, especially for kids). He plays with words quite literally - some of his best characters are words, or dressed in words, or just bad puns. The warriors who the girls early encounter, for example, are binjas - garbage bins with martial arts skills - note one on the cover. Characters include a bird whose cage includes a body to walk it around, a school of fish in a diving suit, and a half-ghost who has to leave his clothes behind to go through walls. There are rooftop dwellers whose roofs sit directly on the ground, houses in bizarre shapes, a moving bridge (the Pons Absconditus) and words that come to life. The plethora of material could be distracting, but becomes an effective phantasmagoria, more of an atmosphere than a book.
At a deeper level, Mieville is playing with the traditional form of this type of story, starting from his decision to abandon the tall blonde Shwazzy after her first reckless encounter, and leave the action to the 'comic sidekick' Deeba, her unreliable book of Shwazzy prophecies ("the Book"), and her lovable animated milk carton, Curdle. Deeba is unconcerned with convention, and focuses on getting the job done, at the expense (thank goodness, did I mention how long this book is?) of the quest form - get a to get b to get c to get d to get the magical UnGun which will allow us to defeat the evil smog? I think not! - instead, Deeba convinces the guardians of the final UnGun that what they really want is the thing she managed to get first. Deeba's refreshing ability to think outside convention brings the book a life and conviction.
In the end, it is entirely appropriate that the UnChosen One has the adventure and saves the day, while the actual Shwazzy is lying on a couch at home with amnesia.
Actually, it does make Alice look rather tame.